Skip to main content

A false tradition

It is stated in Minhaj al Sadiqin that prophet Dawud had nineteen sons, and every one of them wanted to inherit his father's kingdom. Allah sent Dawud nine questions with answers and asked him to appoint the son who gives the correct answers as his successor.

QUESTIONS and ANSWERS:
1. Which is the nearest thing? Hereafter.
2. Which is the farthest thing? Time passed away
2. What phenomenon manifests love? Body with soul.
4. What phenomenon manifests dread? Body without soul.
5. Which things remain the same? Sky and earth.
6. Which things ever remain different? Day and night.
7. Which things are opposed to each other. Life and death.
8. What ends in - goodness? Patience and forbearance at the time of anger.
9. What ends in evil? Haste at the time of anger

None save Sulayman, the youngest son, gave the correct answers, so he was made the heir of Dawud.

Aqa Mahdi Puya says:
The law of inheritance stated in this verse is the law of the Lord, and no one can ever make changes in the laws of the Lord save Himself or the Holy Prophet under His command (Bani Israil : 77). Now refer to the commentary of Bani Israil : 26; Nahl: 90 and Maryam: 2 to 15 for the issue of Fadak. To deprive Bibi Fatimah of her rightful inheritance a false tradition (The prophets of Allah neither inherit nor leave inheritance) was quoted. The Holy Prophet was a law-giver, therefore he could never break any law made by Allah. He was the best exemplar of the laws and doctrines preached by him.

The Holy Prophet said:
"Whenever you hear a tradition attributed to me, compare it with the Quran, and, if there is no contradiction between the two, accept it, otherwise reject it outright."

Dawud who chose Sulayman, a prophet, to inherit his kingdom was also a prophet, therefore the tradition quoted to deprive Bibi Fatimah of her rightful inheritance was undoubtedly false. Please note that the superior most prophet of Allah, Muhammad al Mustafa, was granted all the wisdom, knowledge and authority over all created beings which was given to other prophets, in the highest degree by the most generous giver of all givers.


[Shakir 27:16] And Sulaiman was Dawood's heir, and he said: O men! we have been taught the language of birds, and we have been given all things; most surely this is manifest grace.

[Yusufali 27:16] And Solomon was David's heir. He said: "O ye people! We have been taught the speech of birds, and on us has been bestowed (a little) of all things: this is indeed Grace manifest (from Allah.)"

[Pickthal 27:16] And Solomon was David's heir. And he said: O mankind! Lo! we have been taught the language of birds, and have been given (abundance) of all things. This surely is evident favour.

[Pooya/Ali Commentary 27:16] (see commentary for verse 15)

Popular posts from this blog

Kya Rahib aur fitrus farishta ka waqia sahih hai?

क्या फरिश्ता फितरुस और राहिब का वाक्य सही है? کیا فرشتہ فطرس اور راہب کا واقعہ صحیح ہے؟ Kya Rahib aur fitrus farishta ka waqia sahih hai? Yeh sawal hum ne Grand Ayatullah Shaikh Muhammad Hussain Najafi se December 2012 me kiya tha, unka jawab yaha attached kiya gaya hai Waqia of Fitrus:  When Imam Husain (AS) was born, Allah sent down the angel Jibrail (AS) to congratulate the family.On the way down from the heavens angel Jibrail (AS) passed an island, on which the angel Fitrus was sent to by Allah because he had been naughty. Fitrus had also had his wings taken away by Allah.When Fitrus saw Jibrail (AS) he asked him where he was going. Jibrail (AS) told him that he was going to congratulate the Holy Prophet (SAW) and his family on the birth of Imam Husain (AS).Fitrus asked if he could also go with him. Jibrail (AS) agreed with the permission of Allah and so carried him down to earth.When the angels reached the Holy Prophet (SAW) and congratulated him and his fa...

Inna lillahe wa inna lillahe rajeoon

INNA LILLAHI WA INNA ALAIHI RAJEOON "Surely We Belong To Allah and to Him Shall We Return" Surah 2: 156 Baani of 18th safar julus, Haji Sayyed Mukhtar Hussain Ibne Izhar Hussain at the age of 71, expired ( Natural Death) on Friday  25th September 2020, 7th Safar 1442, this morning at his own residence.  Tadfeen has been completed at rahmatabad kabrastan Mumbai. Request you to please recite Surah e Fateha, Dua e Maghferat &  Namaz e Wahshat and pray for his Maghfirat, May Allah (swt) grant him a place near the vicinity of 14 Masoomeen (as) and give patience to his family members, relatives and friends.  Inshaallah Teeje ki Majlis Sunday 10 am hogi. Address 11/2 Sai Colony Gate no.7, Malwani Malad West Mumbai 400095. Today also the date of Death of Salman al-Farsi, yr 36 AH 

Shahadat of Ameerul Ali ibne Abi Talib (a.s.) - A Nation's Loss

As-Suyuti (Shafi’i scholar) relates that Holy Prophet (s.a.w.s.) said: Love of Ali is faith, and enmity towards him is sedition. (Kanzu 'l-`ummal. In as-Suyuti, Jam`u 'l-jawami `, vol.6, p.156) It was 19th of Ramadhan 41 Hijri while Ameerul Momineen Ali ibne Abi Talib (a.s.) was leading the morning prayers and was in the second sajdah of the 2nd Rakaat that Ibne Muljim’s (l.a.) sword fell and subsequently the life of the greatest warrior saint was taken away to his merciful Lord. This was the time when Ameerul Momineen Ali ibne Abi Talib (a.s.) uttered his famous words : "Fuzto be rabbil Kaaba" - "By the Rab of Kaaba, I am successful". The crime of assassinating Ameerul Momineen Ali ibne Abi Talib (a.s.) remains one of the most cruel, brutal and hideous, because it was not committed against one man, but against the whole rational Islamic leadership. By assassinating Ameerul Momineen Ali ibne Abi Talib (a.s.), they actually aimed at ass...